I am not one of those traumatized, whiny, bitter former Catholics. Although today I consider myself to be an atheist, if I were to somehow suffer a head injury and decide that Christianity really is The Way, I would become a Catholic again. Protestantism seems so sterile and lifeless. Well, I suppose those churches where people speak in unrecognizable languages and fall out in the presence of the lord are kind of jaunty, in their own way. But, for me, a church should contain proper and restrained ceremony, pretty things to look at while your mind wanders during the homily (sermon for you heathen Protestants), incense, gory stories of saints’ lives, and the consumption of the actual body and blood of Christ. No matzo crackers and grape juice for me. When I drop my offering in the basket, I want to get the most bang for my buck. I want a show.
The one thing that would be a disappointment is that the Mass is in English. Back in the day, I enjoyed many a High Mass. Latin, FTW. I’m also not sure about confession. I hear that in some quarters it’s done face to face these days. Something just isn’t right about that. I want the box with the curtain, the screen, and the anonymity. I mean, really. I can just see myself looking Father Nguyen (they’re all Vietnamese in New Orleans these days) in the eye while I regale him with tales of self-abuse. Not going to happen.
I wonder if Father Nguyen takes himself down to the local neighborhood joint for a beer or a cocktail the way Father Gautreaux used to when I was a kid. Probably not. I’ll admit, that was a little traumatizing. Oh, I should mention that I grew up in the 1960s in New Orleans when parents of a certain type would cart their kids along to the restaurant/bar with them. My father and stepmother were those kinds of parents. So, we sometimes ran into Father Gautreaux at the Edgelake or G & Lil’s having a little aperitif. I wasn’t upset that our parish priest was in a bar, nor was I upset that he was having a drink. You may have guessed given the fact that my parents took small children to bars that seeing someone having a drink wasn’t exactly a rare occurrence for me. What upset me was that he wasn’t wearing his black clothing or his collar. There was Father Gautreaux in an open collared plaid sport shirt and regular slacks, sipping his whiskey and soda or whatever he was drinking and looking like a regular person. This totally threw my eight year old’s view of the right and proper WAY THINGS SHOULD BE out of whack.
So, Father Gautreaux in his sport shirts and the time in first grade when I peed on myself during the Stations of the Cross and I had to go to the office and change into a uniform and panties that did not belong to me (who knows where that stuff had been). Oh, and the time during third grade when Mrs. Hunt busted me for having completed my entire math workbook before Halloween. I’m pretty sure that had more to do with Mrs. Hunt not knowing how to deal with a child like me than it did with it being a Catholic school. So, yeah, I came out pretty much unscathed.